Option Payoff & Profit — Calls, Puts and Breakevens
A payoff diagram shows what an option is worth at expiry. Profit adds the premium. Here are the formulas, the breakevens and the shapes that matter.
Payoff is not profit
The payoff of an option at expiry is its intrinsic value then. Profit adds the premium you paid or received at the start. Confusing the two is the most common error in options analysis: a call can finish in the money and still lose money if the premium was higher than the intrinsic gain.
ST is the underlying price at expiry and K is the strike. The payoff is never negative because you can choose not to exercise.
A put pays when the underlying finishes below the strike.
For a short position the sign reverses: profit = premium received − payoff.
Breakeven points
A long call breaks even at K + premium, because the underlying must rise enough to recover the cost. A long put breaks even at K − premium. These are the points where the profit line crosses zero, not where the option becomes intrinsic.
| Position | Payoff | Breakeven | Maximum loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Long call | max(ST − K, 0) | K + premium | Premium paid |
| Long put | max(K − ST, 0) | K − premium | Premium paid |
| Short call | −max(ST − K, 0) | K + premium | Unlimited |
| Short put | −max(K − ST, 0) | K − premium | K − premium |
| Covered call | ST − K above the strike | S0 − premium | Fall in the stock, partly offset |
| Protective put | Floor at K below the strike | S0 + premium | Premium plus the gap to the strike |
Reading the shapes
A long call has a flat loss to the left of the strike and a rising line to the right: limited downside, unlimited upside. A long put is the mirror image. Selling either option flips the diagram vertically, which is why short calls carry unlimited risk while short puts carry large but bounded risk.
The lab plots profit or loss against the underlying at expiry, with the current spot marked. The horizontal axis spans 50% to 150% of the strike so the shape is visible regardless of moneyness. The second chart re-prices the option today at each spot level, which shows the curved, time-dependent value rather than the kinked expiry payoff.
Before expiry the option still has time value, so the value curve is smooth. At expiry time value is zero and the curve becomes the familiar hockey stick. The gap between the two curves is the time value that theta erodes.
Payoff is a snapshot
An expiry diagram ignores what happens before expiry. It says nothing about margin calls, early assignment, volatility changes or the path the underlying takes. Use it to understand the terminal economics, then use the Greeks and the scenario grid in the lab to understand the risk along the way.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between payoff and profit?
Where is the breakeven on a long call?
Can a long call lose more than the premium?
Why does the value curve differ from the payoff line?
Options definitions and risk descriptions are checked against the original Black-Scholes paper and regulator education material.
- SEC Investor.gov — Investor education and financial calculatorsRegulator guidance on compounding, risk, fees and investor rights.
- FINRA — OptionsHow listed options work, including the risks the options lab describes.
- U.S. Department of the TreasuryOfficial data and background on government securities and interest rates.
- U.S. Energy Information AdministrationEnergy prices and conversion factors used by the fuel-cost calculator.
- Black and Scholes (1973) — The Pricing of Options and Corporate LiabilitiesThe original European option-pricing paper implemented in the Black-Scholes lab.
How these are used: sources and standards.
See it in the live model
Open the lab, change an input and watch the option value, Greeks, charts and scenario grid respond.